I’d never thought I’d see the day where I am might disagree with you, but I think it has arrived. Commit murder . . . in what context? Is a human attacked by an animal, any animal, considered murder? Are humans referred to as “murders” when they slaughter those poor animals that end up on our dinner plate? I’d beg to differ. What is the difference between what we do to chickens and other prey a like in the “slaughterhouses” to Edward or any other vampire hunting on their prey through their method of choice? Whether they want to go for the instant kill or do some foreplay. How can that be referred to as murder? Edward isn’t a human, which I believe is something we can all agree on here, and while yes he chooses to live among humans and to some degree assimilate into our way of life . . . I have to ask, does that in any way shed light on the fact that he’s a vampire, first and foremost? No matter how emotionally, mentally and intellectually he might seem similar to us (except to a more superior degree) . . . in my opinion, can never ever, ever possibly be governed by the same laws, morals and ethics us humans go by. And I think this is a quite good point to consider, in Stephenie’s world, humans aren’t top of the pyramid anymore. Vampires are. And regardless of our evolved brain size and superior intelligence in relation to other species we just happen to be the most desirable prey around. So in conclusion, how does a perfectly normal vampire -- normal as in feeding habits -- be considered a murder?Jazz Girl wrote: Are there parts of Edward that we should not idealize? Well, I'd say yes, just as there are characteristics in all of us that are not the best. His superiority complex for one. Edward completely believes himself to be infallible in some things, above reproach. That one is just irritating as all hell and leads to much of the conflict between he and Bella. Edward also struggles with his jealousy. He is extremely possessive of Bella. And, while we rarely see it's expression (save a few key examples), it isn't the best way to be. And, regardless of his motivations, methods and intentions, he has committed murder. Edward is certainly flawed. That is part of what makes him so fascinating.
Sorry to go of on a tangent. It's late. I am easily frustrated. And I need something to distract me from a looming Biology test. I am just trying to say I wish I could have more time to reply to everything else. I suppose tomorrow . . . sigh